Stock-Picking amid Chronic Low Rates - Lessons from Japan

Clay Smolinski,

Graduating as dux of Finance from university and a brief stint as an accountant at Grant Thornton gave Clay the grounding to deconstruct financial statements. Having started.. More

18 May 2016

A prolonged period of low interest rates will affect us all, and the question of which stocks to own requires more careful consideration than ever before.

This is an edited extract from the presentation given by Clay Smolinski at the 2016 Platinum Asset Management Investor and Adviser Forums. It followed a presentation given by Andrew Clifford, “Interest rates to be lower for much longer”, providing an overview of the current macroeconomic environment from a historical perspective.

The passive index-tracking approach that has served many in the last few years appears to be becoming fashionable at exactly the wrong time.

The key effects will be threefold:

  • Retirement incomes – many people retiring now or recently would have expected, and built their plans around, safe 5-6% yields being readily available. With this off the table, behaviour will be forced to change.
  • Valuation – how do we value stocks if the risk-free rate of return is at or close to zero? We have seen price-to-earnings (P/E) ratios average about 15X (or earnings yields approaching 7%) over the past 50 years with risk-free rates averaging around 5%. If this falls to 1% for a prolonged period, where will earnings yields (and their inverse, P/E ratios) trend to?
  • With negative rates specifically, we are in uncharted territory. Two years ago negative rates did not exist; now we have two of the world’s largest economies, Europe and Japan, operating under such conditions. This was once unthinkable, and the rules are still being learnt.

Although negative rates are unprecedented, we have seen extended periods of low rates before. Japan, being a country where the interest rate has been below 1% for over 20 years, offers an interesting case study. Platinum is unique among Australian asset managers to have managed a dedicated Japan fund* for 18 years, which has over that period delivered 14.6% per annum against a market return of about 1.5% p.a. (MSCI Japan Index in $A)[1]. We have direct experience of what worked in a low rate environment and, importantly, the distortions that low rates caused.

This paper will address three key strategies that worked and one to avoid, and will (in the footnotes) provide some examples of stocks we own today that meet these criteria. The analysis draws from a series of back-testing done by Credit Suisse HOLT as well as Platinum’s own quantitative studies. It is worth noting that the strategies shared by Credit Suisse would have also worked in the US and Europe, as they rely on investing common sense, but to a much lesser extent.

  • Growth[2] – Japanese investors became very enthusiastic for stocks that showed growth and would often bid them up to very high valuation levels. This can be explained by scarcity in a slow economy. However, simply buying growth would have been unsuccessful if it was not accompanied by keen attention to price. Our own quantitative work suggests that paying around 20X P/E (or below) for companies growing consistently at 7% or more delivered handsomely in Japan.
  • Dividend yields[3] – back-testing by Credit Suisse shows that consistent superior returns could be obtained in Japan (more so than in the US and Europe) by investing in the top quintile (i.e. the top 20%) of stocks with the highest dividend yields within sectors. Again, scarcity of income, this time across asset classes (i.e. stocks versus bonds or bank deposits), was the simple driver.
  • Contrarian investing – Credit Suisse’s back-testing also suggests that paying attention to value and going against the crowd had substantial rewards. Buying the cheapest quintile of stocks across sectors based on the price–to-book ratio[4] was more successful in Japan than elsewhere. In particular, a subset defined by Credit Suisse as “Restructuring” – cheap companies with low returns but improving momentum – was the best strategy of all, which indicates that detecting positive change among cheap stocks was the most effective approach.[5]
  • One to avoid – what Credit Suisse termed the “Quality Trap”. These are quality stocks that have become expensive but where their momentum is in decline. This can be dangerous. We often hear the standard marketing spin trotted out about why we should invest in great companies. Of course it is compelling logic and comforting to own the “best” companies, but they do not make the best investments. This is true in all markets over the long-term, but was especially so in Japan.

In summary, an investment approach like Platinum’s – paying close attention to price and going against the herd – makes a lot of sense and is effective, particularly in a market like Japan where there is little growth in the economy and interest rates are already close to zero. There was a widespread sense in Japan that the economy was very vulnerable to shocks and that the policy-makers had used up all their bullets. So when problems did arise, whether it was at a company level or a macro level, one would often see wild swings in sentiment and investors would get very pessimistic. If the world today indeed resembles the Japan of the last two to three decades, then we expect our tried-and-tested stock selection approach will have a good chance of delivering solid outcomes for our investors in the years ahead.


* Australian-domiciled product. Not part of Platinum World Portfolios PLC.


[1] As at 31 March 2016. Fund returns are calculated using the Platinum Japan Fund’s unit price and represent the combined income and capital return since inception on 30 June 1998. Fund returns are net of fees and costs (excluding the buy-sell spread and any investment performance fee payable), are pre-tax, and assume the reinvestment of distributions. The investment returns shown are historical and no warranty can be given for future performance. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance.
[2] Defined by us to include stocks with a P/E ratio of less than 22X forward earnings and trailing growth for the last five years in sales per share of 8% or more. Key holdings in the Platinum International Fund (as at 9 May 2016) that meet these criteria include Alphabet (formerly known as Google), China Mobile, Gilead Sciences (American biopharmaceutical company), Kweichow Moutai (Chinese premium liquor producer) and ICICI Bank.
[3] Based on Credit Suisse HOLT’s analysis, stocks in the top quintile of the global universe (for simplicity, not adjusted for sectors) have a dividend yield of greater than 3.75%. Key holdings in the Platinum International Fund (as at 9 May 2016) that meet this benchmark include AstraZeneca (UK-based pharmaceutical and biologics company), Groupe Casino (French mass retailer with supermarket chains around the world), Eni (Italian multinational oil and gas company), Intesa Sanpaolo (Italian banking group) and Ericsson.
[4] Stocks in the bottom quintile of the global universe (not sector-adjusted) in Credit Suisse HOLT’s analysis have a P/B ratio of less than 1.0. Holdings in the Platinum International Fund’s portfolio (as at 9 May 2016) that meet this criterion include Lixil (Japanese manufacturer of building materials and housing equipment), Inpex (Japanese oil company), Toyota Industries, Sina (Chinese online media group) and Sberbank (Russian banking and financial services company).
[5] The following holdings in the Platinum International Fund’s portfolio (as at 9 May 2016) have these attractive traits: Carnival Cruise Line, Cisco (American technology giant), Daiichi Sankyo (Japanese pharmaceutical company), GAIL (Indian gas company), Genting (Malaysian conglomerate), KB Financial (Korean financial services company), Lloyds Bank, Newcrest Mining and Samsung Electronics.


DISCLAIMER: The above information is commentary only (i.e. our general thoughts). It is not intended to be, nor should it be construed as, investment advice. To the extent permitted by law, no liability is accepted for any loss or damage as a result of any reliance on this information. Before making any investment decision you need to consider (with your financial adviser) your particular investment needs, objectives and circumstances. The above material may not be reproduced, in whole or in part, without the prior written consent of Platinum Investment Management Limited.

You may also find interesting...

Terms and Conditions

Dated: 9 March 2022
IMPORTANT NOTICE – Please read this important notice before proceeding.

This website,, is operated by Platinum World Portfolios PLC, a variable capital investment company incorporated under the laws of Ireland under Registered Number 546481 ("the Company", “we” or “us”).

By proceeding to access, view or download information from this website, you acknowledge that you have read, and agree to be bound by, the following terms and conditions. If you do not agree to these terms and conditions, you must not use this website.

  • Distribution of the information contained on this website in certain jurisdictions may be restricted by law. The information contained on this website is intended only for persons and entities in those jurisdictions where access to such information and use thereof is not contrary to local laws or regulations. Accordingly, all persons who access this website are required to inform themselves and to comply with such restrictions. In addition, this website and its contents have not been prepared for and are not intended for access by US persons as defined in the Securities Act of 1933.
  • This is a marketing communication. This is not a contractually binding document. Prior to making any investment in the Company, please refer to the Company’s Prospectus and to the relevant Key Investor Information Documents(“KIID”) and do not base any final investment decision on this communication alone.
  • For persons resident in the United Kingdom or the European Union (“UK or EU persons”): You are about to enter a website which contains information aimed at professional clients within the meaning of Article 4.1(10) of the Markets in Financial Services Directive 2014/65/EU (MiFID II) (“Professional Client”). If you are a UK or EU person, by entering this website you confirm that you are a Professional Client. This website does not constitute an offer or invitation to subscribe for shares in the Company and no UK or EU person other than a Professional Client should act or rely on this website. Platinum UK Asset Management Limited of 20 North Audley Street, London W1K 6LX (“PAM UK”) has been appointed as the sub-distributor of the Company in the United Kingdom. PAM UK is an appointed representative of Mirabella Advisers LLP which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority - number 606792. Platinum Management Malta Limited of 171, Old Bakery Street, Valletta VLT 1455, Malta (“PAM Malta”) has been appointed as the sub-distributor of the Company in certain European Union member states. PAM Malta is a tied agent of Mirabella Malta Advisers Limited, which is licensed and regulated by the Malta Financial Services Authority. The content of this website has been approved by both Mirabella Advisers LLP and Mirabella Malta Advisers Limited.
  • When using this website, you are responsible for complying with all applicable local, national and international laws and regulations, including those related to data privacy and intellectual property. It may be illegal to access or download the information contained on this website in certain jurisdictions and we disclaim all responsibility if you access or download any information from this website in breach of any law or regulation of the jurisdiction in which you reside or from which you are accessing this website.
  • The investment funds, strategies and financial products and services described in this website may not be available in all jurisdictions and may not be available to some or all investors in a certain jurisdiction. Nothing contained on this website constitutes or is intended to constitute an offer or a solicitation to subscribe for, redeem or convert shares in the Company or any of its sub-funds in any jurisdiction in which such an offer or solicitation is not authorised or to any person to whom it is unlawful to make such an offer or solicitation. Investments into any fund or sub-fund referred to on this website or any other Platinum product or strategy can only be made through and in accordance with information contained in the relevant offering and subscription documents.
  • The content on this website is provided for general information only. Nothing contained on this website is intended to constitute investment, legal, tax, accounting or other advice. We strongly suggest that investors consult financial and other professional advisers prior to taking, or refraining from, any action on the basis of the content on this website and that you carefully consider your particular investment needs, objectives and financial circumstances. This website does not take into account the investment objectives, financial situation or particular needs of any person and should not be used as the basis for making investment, financial or other decisions. The information is selective and may not be complete or accurate for your particular purposes and should not be construed as a recommendation to invest in any particular investment strategy, security, fund, sub-fund or product, whether or not offered by the Company.
  • The information provided on this website is given in good faith and is believed to be accurate at the time of compilation. The Company may, without notice, amend or remove any information on or from this website at any time. Neither the Company nor any of its directors, officers or agents (including, without limitation, the Company’s investment manager, administrator or custodian) make any representation or warranty as to the accuracy, reliability, timeliness or completeness of the information. To the extent permissible by law, the Company and its directors, officer and agents (including, without limitation, the Company’s investment manager, administrator or custodian) disclaim all liability (whether arising in contract, tort, negligence or otherwise) for any error, omission, loss or damage (whether direct, indirect, consequential or otherwise). To the extent permitted by law, we exclude all conditions, warranties, representations or other terms which may apply to our website or any content on it, whether express or implied.
  • Opinions expressed on this website reflects our views only at the time at which such opinions are expressed and may depend on assumptions or projections that may not prove to be correct or are subject to change.
  • This website may provide information, articles and material, or links to such, that are written or prepared by people who are not associated with the Company. This material is only provided for your interest and convenience. The Company is not responsible for the content or accuracy of this material and any opinion expressed in the material should not be taken as an endorsement, recommendation or opinion of the Company.
  • We do not guarantee that this website, or any content on it, will always be available or be uninterrupted. Access to this website is permitted on a temporary basis. We may suspend, withdraw, discontinue or change all or any part of this website without notice. We will not be liable to you if for any reason this website is unavailable at any time or for any period. You are responsible for making all arrangements necessary for you to have access to this website. You are also responsible for ensuring that all persons who access this website through your internet connection are aware of these terms of use and other applicable terms and conditions, and that they comply with them.
  • Performance figures quoted on this website are past performance. Past performance is not an indicator of future performance. Neither the Company nor any of its directors, officers or agents (including, without limitation, the Company’s investment manager, administrator or custodian) or any associate guarantee or make any representation as to the performance of any of the sub-funds offered by the Company, the maintenance or repayment of capital, the price at which shares in the Company or any of its sub-funds may trade or any particular rate of return.
  • Your acknowledge that neither MSCI Inc. nor any other party involved in or related to compiling, computing or creating any of the MSCI index data referred to on this website makes any express or implied warranties or representations with respect to such data (or the results to be obtained by the use thereof), and all such parties hereby expressly disclaim all warranties of originality, accuracy, completeness, merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose with respect to any of such data. Without limiting any of the foregoing, in no event shall MSCI Inc., any of its affiliates or any third party involved in or related to compiling, computing or creating the data have any liability for any direct, indirect, special, punitive, consequential or any other damages (including lost profits) even if notified of the possibility of such damages. No further distribution or dissemination of the MSCI index data is permitted without express written consent of MSCI Inc.
  • You acknowledge and agree that the collection, disclosure or use of information about you from accessing this website is subject to the terms of the Company's Privacy Policy.
  • The Company may from time to time amend the terms and conditions of accessing this website by posting an amended version of this notice on this website. You agree to continue to be bound by any amended terms and conditions and that the Company has no obligation to notify you of such amendments other than by posting an amended version of this notice on this website.
  • The Company owns the copyright in the content contained in this website (other than materials that have been included with the permission of others who own the applicable copyright). You may print a copy of any page for personal or non-commercial purposes provided that you do not remove any copyright notices or any trademarks or logos of the Company or persons or entities associated with it. Except for a purpose or a use permitted by statute, or the prior written consent of the Company, you must not copy, modify, sell, distribute, adapt, publish, frame, reproduce or otherwise use any of the material on this website or trademarks or logos of the Company or persons or entities associated with it.
  • These terms and conditions of use are be governed by and construed in accordance with the laws of Ireland, and you agree to the non-exclusive jurisdiction of the Courts of Ireland.